Posted on May 4, 2025

Boating Ban on Sylvan Lake Sparks Local Meltdown

40

Rome City, IN — In a decision that left lakefront residents confused, irritated, and aggressively Googling “DNR overreach,” Indiana officials temporarily banned full-speed boating on Sylvan Lake and the West Lakes Chain. The official reason? “High water levels.” The unofficial reason? Someone in a kayak got wet and filed a complaint.

The Department of Natural Resources claimed the move was to “protect shoreline structures.” Locals claim it was to protect delicate egos and overpriced docks installed by guys named Todd.

“The lake’s not too high,” said longtime resident Cheryl Whitman. “It’s just too wet for people who don’t know how to boat without screaming like they’re storming Normandy.”

Cheryl, like most Rome City residents, didn’t take kindly to the restrictions. Neither did her neighbor Ron, who spent the week rage-riding his lawnmower up and down the property line with a sign reading “Let My Wake Go.”

“It’s tyranny,” Ron said. “They say ‘idle speed only.’ Well guess what, Karen? I am idle speed. That’s my cruising gear.”

Tempers have flared since the ban went into effect, mostly on Facebook, where lake groups turned into digital war zones. One woman compared the DNR to the Gestapo, another called it “Biden’s lake lockdown,” and at least three people posted blurry photos of perfectly calm water with the caption “explain this.”

Even the fish seemed confused.

“You ever seen a bluegill roll its eyes?” said local bait shop owner Mitch Crabtree. “One swam up to me and said, ‘Get your human drama off my lawn.’ I swear.”

At the heart of the issue is Rome City’s eternal conflict: peace and quiet vs. beer and horsepower. On one side, retirees with binoculars and six decades of suppressed anger. On the other, middle-aged men on $30,000 jet skis who think sunscreen is a government scam.

“This lake used to be peaceful,” said one homeowner as she sprayed her lawn with mosquito repellent and judgment. “Now it’s Daytona on water. Someone needs to do something before another floating trampoline shows up.”

The DNR apparently agreed — or at least got enough noise complaints to fake agreement. So, out came the idle-speed orders. Gone were the wakeboards, the tubing, the glorious sound of someone hitting the water at 28 mph and immediately regretting it.

Boaters were pissed.

Bars were empty.

And at least one guy tried to sue the lake for emotional distress.

“They told us it was for ‘safety,’” said Doug Henderson, who owns two boats and zero chill. “But I’ve seen safer behavior at a family reunion with fireworks and unresolved trauma.”

Doug now spends his afternoons sitting at the public dock, holding a fishing pole with no line on it, just to make a point. “I’m fishing for freedom,” he said. “Catch and release.”

Meanwhile, lakefront property owners were split. Some supported the restrictions, claiming it was the only way to keep their seawalls from crumbling. Others admitted the only thing cracking their walls was age, bad concrete, and Gary slamming the throttle while trying to impress women who don’t exist.

Gary, it turns out, was at the center of the storm. Known for blasting classic rock at medically unsafe volumes and owning a pontoon with a beer fridge and zero brakes, Gary became the unofficial scapegoat for all lake-related grievances.

“He’s a menace,” Cheryl said. “Last summer he tried to do donuts in a paddleboat. We thought it was a mating ritual.”

In defense of his lifestyle, Gary told BSW News: “The lake is for living, not lurking. You don’t like the splash, move to the pool.”

As restrictions lingered, creativity blossomed. One group hosted a silent disco on paddleboards. Another started “wake-free drag races,” where the only rule was you couldn’t move. A man in a canoe held a funeral for his throttle control. No one cried, but several people nodded solemnly while drinking out of gas station coffee cups filled with vodka.

Even the geese seemed smug.

“They were strutting around like they own the place,” said Mitch. “One hissed at me like I owed it rent.”

After a week of unrest, the restrictions were lifted. No ceremony. No apology. Just a quiet update buried in a PDF on a government website that hasn’t been updated since the Obama administration.

Boats fired up within minutes.

Gary was on the water within ten.

And Ron drove his lawnmower into the lake on purpose, calling it a “symbolic gesture of resistance.”

The DNR has declined to comment further, likely because their inbox is full of poorly spelled threats and memes about lake tyranny. But one official, speaking on condition of anonymity, admitted the whole ordeal “got out of hand quicker than a Fourth of July sparkler in a dry field.”

As for Rome City, things are back to normal — which is to say passive-aggressively tense.

The lake is loud.

The beer is warm.

The binoculars are watching.

And somewhere, Gary is cranking up Def Leppard and heading toward another confrontation with shoreline law enforcement and personal accountability.

Stay dry, Indiana.